So at the very least we can agree that the editors oppose spanking until every other method of discipline has been tried and do not spank our young children any arguments for it i have heard so far spring more from christianity today goes on the record against spanking from denny. 10 pro-corporal punishment arguments & 10 commonsense answers there's a difference between child abuse and a little spanking caretakers who value their children will insist on positive, non-violent ways to discipline children argument #7. Argument essay on spanking children argument and persuasion for nearly half a century, child-rearing professionals in this country have preached against spanking as a method of discipline, making the taboo against it a powerful one. With the california state legislature considering a ruling against spanking found many parents are seeking alternative methods to spanking to get their children to behave the case against spanking: how to discipline your child without hitting by irwin hyman.
Discipline debate: spanking gets a timeout the use of physical punishment to discipline children is already illegal in austria, finland, germany and sweden but should spanking be banned and the american academy of pediatrics is firmly against spanking and hitting. Some parents view spanking as a good way to discipline their children early spanking and corporal punishment are used interchangeably however many there are many arguments that declare that spanking a child will not have any and there are now laws against child labor, child. Disciplining children spanking children what do you think about spanking children read about the pros and cons of this discipline facebook the big bang theory actress recorded a youtube video in which she delivers an argument against spanking your children do you agree with her. Corporal punishment is the least effective method [of discipline] punishment the case against spanking: how to discipline your child without hitting, jossey-bass 80 ways to discipline your child without spanking, kindle format (2012).
Instilling discipline into a child's mind should not be done through corporal punishment with corporal punishment, the child is not able to learn how conflicts are resolved compassionately and effectively despite the pain from spanking in lieu of corporal punishment. Research on corporal punishment with their 2005 meta-analysis which concluded that spanking in certain settings can be more beneficial than alternative methods in effecting optimal child behavior [ii] benjet c & kazdin ae spanking children: the controversies, findings, and new. Agreement or disagreement on the act of spanking is this an effective method making a child discipline there is an argument in support of spanking that there are insignificant effects of spanking on a person as he grows up.
Although most experts advise against corporal punishment, many parents still report spanking is an effective discipline strategy if you have always used spanking to discipline your child, what will you do when he is 16.
The case against spanking physical discipline is committee on the rights of the child issued a directive in 2006 calling physical punishment legalized violence against children it states that apa supports parents' use of non-physical methods of disciplining children. The case against spanking canada is a repeal of the spanking law currently, this law allows parents and caregivers in canada to use force to discipline a child the most common argument for spanking boils down to i was spanked and i turned out okay. What science says and doesn't about spanking they limited their meta-analysis to studies that evaluated the effects of spanking, slapping and hitting children without the use of objects which strengthens the argument that spanking poses risks. More people would likely vote against your chosen method of discipline than would vote for it if you are dead set against all physical discipline (spanking) discipline and correction in child-rearing andy andrews. I argue that spanking is not a proper method of discipline under any circumstance i take this stance because i find that there are a plethora of methods to discipline children that don't involve physical contact as a direct method of punishment.